Follow the Weird Idea: How to Trust and Develop Your Most Original Creative Instincts

follow your weird idea trust creative instincts

You get a strange idea.
It excites you—but also makes you nervous.
It doesn’t fit the trends. It’s not “marketable.” It doesn’t look like what anyone else is doing.

So you shelve it.
Or you polish it down until it’s safer, cleaner, more acceptable.

But here’s the truth: your weirdest ideas are often your best ones.
And if you want to create work that stands out—work that lasts—you have to follow them.

In this article, you’ll learn:

  • Why weird ideas matter (and where they come from)
  • How to tell the difference between weird/good and weird/bad
  • A step-by-step process for developing original ideas
  • How to stay focused and courageous through the uncertainty

Why the Weird Ideas Are Often the Most Valuable

If it’s weird, it means it didn’t come from someone else.
It didn’t come from the algorithm, the trend cycle, or your fear of being ignored.

It came from your unfiltered self—the part that’s curious, nonlinear, associative, and deeply human.

Neuroscience calls this divergent thinking: your brain’s ability to make unexpected connections across distant ideas or experiences.

That’s where original creative work is born.
Not from what’s expected—but from what surprises even you.

What Makes Weird Ideas So Hard to Trust

  • 😨 They feel risky: “What if no one gets it?”
  • 📉 They lack external proof: “This doesn’t look like success.”
  • 🎭 They challenge identity: “Do I even know what I’m doing?”
  • 📦 They don’t fit neat boxes: “What category is this even in?”

But that discomfort is often a signal—not of danger, but of originality.

The job isn’t to eliminate the fear. It’s to walk with it.

How to Tell If a Weird Idea Is Worth Pursuing

Ask yourself:

  • 💡 “Does this idea energize me—even if it scares me?”
  • 🧠 “Is there a part of me that keeps returning to it?”
  • 🌱 “Do I feel like this could evolve into something no one’s seen before?”

You don’t need a guarantee. You just need a pulse.

The 5-Phase Process of Developing a Weird Idea

1. ✍️ Sketch the Instinct

Capture it quickly. Don’t overthink.
Write it down in its rawest form, even if it feels incoherent.

  • Give it a working title, phrase, or shape
  • Describe the feeling behind it (What does it want to express?)
  • Don’t edit—just record

2. 📓 Surround the Idea

Collect inputs that resonate with the idea’s energy—colors, moods, songs, images, memories, quotes, contrasting concepts.

Create a moodboard, playlist, or visual dump.
This gives your subconscious more to work with.

mind lab pro

3. 🔬 Find the Structure

Once the emotional core is strong, start shaping it.
What format does it want to live in?

  • Is it a short story? A visual series? A concept for a product?
  • Can it be broken down into parts or phases?
  • What would “version 1” look like in its simplest form?

You don’t need a final draft—you need a test form.

4. 🧪 Build a Low-Risk Prototype

Make a small, safe version.
A single piece. A sample. A short pilot. A quick mockup.

  • Don’t aim for perfection—aim for momentum
  • Keep the stakes low so fear doesn’t take over
  • Share with one trusted peer if you’re comfortable

5. 🔁 Iterate with Curiosity

Once it exists—even in rough form—start responding to it.

  • What’s working?
  • What’s it really about?
  • What new ideas has it sparked?

The first draft of a weird idea often isn’t quite right.
But if you keep following the energy, it will evolve into something wholly your own.

How to Stay Brave While Working on an Unconventional Idea

  • 🧘 Anchor in process, not outcome (create for the work, not for likes)
  • 🔐 Share selectively in early stages (protect the fragile phase)
  • 🎯 Set emotional goals: “I want to finish this draft and feel proud of the exploration.”
  • 💬 Create a short mantra: “This might be strange—but it might be brilliant.”

Courage grows with repetition. Every weird idea you follow makes the next one easier.

Brain Support for Deep, Unfiltered Creativity

Working on strange or original ideas requires emotional resilience, cognitive clarity, and creative courage.

I use Mind Lab Pro during high-uncertainty creative phases for support:

  • L-Theanine: Eases tension so ideas can emerge more freely
  • Citicoline: Sharpens clarity when you’re refining messy concepts
  • Rhodiola: Helps manage emotional resistance and self-doubt
  • Lion’s Mane: Supports the neural flexibility needed for original thinking

👉 Explore the Creative’s Supplement Guide →

Final Thoughts: Your Weird Idea Is a Gift

The world doesn’t need more polish. It needs more honesty.
More experiments. More boldness. More risk. More joy.

If something inside you is tugging on a strange thread—follow it.
Not because it’s safe. Not because it’s guaranteed.
But because it’s yours.